salt/tests/integration/modules/test_state.py

# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-

# Import python libs
from __future__ import absolute_import
import os
import shutil
import tempfile
import textwrap
import threading
import time

# Import Salt Testing libs
from tests.support.case import ModuleCase
from tests.support.unit import skipIf
from tests.support.paths import TMP
from tests.support.mixins import SaltReturnAssertsMixin

# Import salt libs
import salt.utils
from salt.modules.virtualenv_mod import KNOWN_BINARY_NAMES

# Import 3rd-party libs
import salt.ext.six as six


class StateModuleTest(ModuleCase, SaltReturnAssertsMixin):
    '''
    Validate the state module
    '''

    maxDiff = None

    def test_show_highstate(self):
        '''
        state.show_highstate
        '''
        high = self.run_function('state.show_highstate')
        destpath = os.path.join(TMP, 'testfile')
        self.assertTrue(isinstance(high, dict))
        self.assertTrue(destpath in high)
        self.assertEqual(high[destpath]['__env__'], 'base')

    def test_show_lowstate(self):
        '''
        state.show_lowstate
        '''
        low = self.run_function('state.show_lowstate')
        self.assertTrue(isinstance(low, list))
        self.assertTrue(isinstance(low[0], dict))

    def test_catch_recurse(self):
        '''
        state.show_sls used to catch a recursive ref
        '''
        err = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='recurse_fail')
        self.assertIn('recursive', err[0])

    def test_no_recurse(self):
        '''
        verify that a sls structure is NOT a recursive ref
        '''
        sls = self.run_function('state.show_sls', mods='recurse_ok')
        self.assertIn('snmpd', sls)

    def test_no_recurse_two(self):
        '''
        verify that a sls structure is NOT a recursive ref
        '''
        sls = self.run_function('state.show_sls', mods='recurse_ok_two')
        self.assertIn('/etc/nagios/nrpe.cfg', sls)

    def test_running_dictionary_consistency(self):
        '''
        Test the structure of the running dictionary so we don't change it
        without deprecating/documenting the change
        '''
        running_dict_fields = [
            '__id__',
            '__run_num__',
            '__sls__',
            'changes',
            'comment',
            'duration',
            'name',
            'result',
            'start_time',
        ]

        sls = self.run_function('state.single',
                fun='test.succeed_with_changes',
                name='gndn')

        for state, ret in sls.items():
            for field in running_dict_fields:
                self.assertIn(field, ret)

    def test_running_dictionary_key_sls(self):
        '''
        Ensure the __sls__ key is either null or a string
        '''
        sls1 = self.run_function('state.single',
                fun='test.succeed_with_changes',
                name='gndn')

        sls2 = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='gndn')

        for state, ret in sls1.items():
            self.assertTrue(isinstance(ret['__sls__'], type(None)))

        for state, ret in sls2.items():
            self.assertTrue(isinstance(ret['__sls__'], str))

    def _remove_request_cache_file(self):
        '''
        remove minion state request file
        '''
        cache_file = os.path.join(self.get_config('minion')['cachedir'], 'req_state.p')
        if os.path.exists(cache_file):
            os.remove(cache_file)

    def test_request(self):
        '''
        verify sending a state request to the minion(s)
        '''
        self._remove_request_cache_file()

        ret = self.run_function('state.request', mods='modules.state.requested')
        result = ret['cmd_|-count_root_dir_contents_|-ls -a / | wc -l_|-run']['result']
        self.assertEqual(result, None)

    def test_check_request(self):
        '''
        verify checking a state request sent to the minion(s)
        '''
        self._remove_request_cache_file()

        self.run_function('state.request', mods='modules.state.requested')
        ret = self.run_function('state.check_request')
        result = ret['default']['test_run']['cmd_|-count_root_dir_contents_|-ls -a / | wc -l_|-run']['result']
        self.assertEqual(result, None)

    def test_clear_request(self):
        '''
        verify clearing a state request sent to the minion(s)
        '''
        self._remove_request_cache_file()

        self.run_function('state.request', mods='modules.state.requested')
        ret = self.run_function('state.clear_request')
        self.assertTrue(ret)

    def test_run_request_succeeded(self):
        '''
        verify running a state request sent to the minion(s)
        '''
        self._remove_request_cache_file()

        if salt.utils.is_windows():
            self.run_function('state.request', mods='modules.state.requested_win')
        else:
            self.run_function('state.request', mods='modules.state.requested')

        ret = self.run_function('state.run_request')

        if salt.utils.is_windows():
            key = 'cmd_|-count_root_dir_contents_|-Get-ChildItem C:\\\\ | Measure-Object | %{$_.Count}_|-run'
        else:
            key = 'cmd_|-count_root_dir_contents_|-ls -a / | wc -l_|-run'

        result = ret[key]['result']
        self.assertTrue(result)

    def test_run_request_failed_no_request_staged(self):
        '''
        verify not running a state request sent to the minion(s)
        '''
        self._remove_request_cache_file()

        self.run_function('state.request', mods='modules.state.requested')
        self.run_function('state.clear_request')
        ret = self.run_function('state.run_request')
        self.assertEqual(ret, {})

    def test_issue_1896_file_append_source(self):
        '''
        Verify that we can append a file's contents
        '''
        testfile = os.path.join(TMP, 'test.append')
        if os.path.isfile(testfile):
            os.unlink(testfile)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='testappend')
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='testappend.step-1')
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='testappend.step-2')
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        with salt.utils.fopen(testfile, 'r') as fp_:
            testfile_contents = fp_.read()

        contents = textwrap.dedent('''\
            # set variable identifying the chroot you work in (used in the prompt below)
            if [ -z "$debian_chroot" ] && [ -r /etc/debian_chroot ]; then
                debian_chroot=$(cat /etc/debian_chroot)
            fi

            # enable bash completion in interactive shells
            if [ -f /etc/bash_completion ] && ! shopt -oq posix; then
                . /etc/bash_completion
            fi
            ''')

        if salt.utils.is_windows():
            new_contents = contents.splitlines()
            contents = os.linesep.join(new_contents)
            contents += os.linesep

        self.assertMultiLineEqual(
                contents, testfile_contents)

        # Re-append switching order
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='testappend.step-2')
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='testappend.step-1')
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        with salt.utils.fopen(testfile, 'r') as fp_:
            testfile_contents = fp_.read()

        self.assertMultiLineEqual(contents, testfile_contents)

    def test_issue_1876_syntax_error(self):
        '''
        verify that we catch the following syntax error::

            /tmp/salttest/issue-1876:

              file:
                - managed
                - source: salt://testfile

              file.append:
                - text: foo

        '''
        testfile = os.path.join(TMP, 'issue-1876')
        sls = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='issue-1876')
        self.assertIn(
            'ID \'{0}\' in SLS \'issue-1876\' contains multiple state '
            'declarations of the same type'.format(testfile),
            sls
        )

    def test_issue_1879_too_simple_contains_check(self):
        expected = textwrap.dedent('''\
            # set variable identifying the chroot you work in (used in the prompt below)
            if [ -z "$debian_chroot" ] && [ -r /etc/debian_chroot ]; then
                debian_chroot=$(cat /etc/debian_chroot)
            fi
            # enable bash completion in interactive shells
            if [ -f /etc/bash_completion ] && ! shopt -oq posix; then
                . /etc/bash_completion
            fi
            ''')

        if salt.utils.is_windows():
            new_contents = expected.splitlines()
            expected = os.linesep.join(new_contents)
            expected += os.linesep

        testfile = os.path.join(TMP, 'issue-1879')
        # Delete if exiting
        if os.path.isfile(testfile):
            os.unlink(testfile)

        # Create the file
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='issue-1879', timeout=120)
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        # The first append
        ret = self.run_function(
            'state.sls', mods='issue-1879.step-1', timeout=120
        )
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        # The second append
        ret = self.run_function(
            'state.sls', mods='issue-1879.step-2', timeout=120
        )
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        # Does it match?
        try:
            with salt.utils.fopen(testfile, 'r') as fp_:
                contents = fp_.read()
            self.assertMultiLineEqual(expected, contents)
            # Make sure we don't re-append existing text
            ret = self.run_function(
                'state.sls', mods='issue-1879.step-1', timeout=120
            )
            self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

            ret = self.run_function(
                'state.sls', mods='issue-1879.step-2', timeout=120
            )
            self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

            with salt.utils.fopen(testfile, 'r') as fp_:
                contents = fp_.read()
            self.assertMultiLineEqual(expected, contents)
        except Exception:
            if os.path.exists(testfile):
                shutil.copy(testfile, testfile + '.bak')
            raise
        finally:
            if os.path.exists(testfile):
                os.unlink(testfile)

    def test_include(self):
        tempdir = tempfile.mkdtemp(dir=TMP)
        self.addCleanup(shutil.rmtree, tempdir, ignore_errors=True)
        pillar = {}
        for path in ('include-test', 'to-include-test', 'exclude-test'):
            pillar[path] = os.path.join(tempdir, path)
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='include-test', pillar=pillar)
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)
        self.assertTrue(os.path.isfile(pillar['include-test']))
        self.assertTrue(os.path.isfile(pillar['to-include-test']))
        self.assertFalse(os.path.isfile(pillar['exclude-test']))

    def test_exclude(self):
        tempdir = tempfile.mkdtemp(dir=TMP)
        self.addCleanup(shutil.rmtree, tempdir, ignore_errors=True)
        pillar = {}
        for path in ('include-test', 'exclude-test', 'to-include-test'):
            pillar[path] = os.path.join(tempdir, path)
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='exclude-test', pillar=pillar)
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)
        self.assertTrue(os.path.isfile(pillar['include-test']))
        self.assertTrue(os.path.isfile(pillar['exclude-test']))
        self.assertFalse(os.path.isfile(pillar['to-include-test']))

    @skipIf(salt.utils.which_bin(KNOWN_BINARY_NAMES) is None, 'virtualenv not installed')
    def test_issue_2068_template_str(self):
        venv_dir = os.path.join(
            TMP, 'issue-2068-template-str'
        )

        try:
            ret = self.run_function(
                'state.sls', mods='issue-2068-template-str-no-dot',
                timeout=120
            )
            self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)
        finally:
            if os.path.isdir(venv_dir):
                shutil.rmtree(venv_dir)

        # Let's load the template from the filesystem. If running this state
        # with state.sls works, so should using state.template_str
        template_path = os.path.join(
            os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(__file__)),
            'files', 'file', 'base', 'issue-2068-template-str-no-dot.sls'
        )

        with salt.utils.fopen(template_path, 'r') as fp_:
            template = fp_.read()
            ret = self.run_function(
                'state.template_str', [template], timeout=120
            )
            self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        # Now using state.template
        ret = self.run_function(
            'state.template', [template_path], timeout=120
        )
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        # Now the problematic #2068 including dot's
        ret = self.run_function(
            'state.sls', mods='issue-2068-template-str', timeout=120
        )
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        # Let's load the template from the filesystem. If running this state
        # with state.sls works, so should using state.template_str
        template_path = os.path.join(
            os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(__file__)),
            'files', 'file', 'base', 'issue-2068-template-str.sls'
        )

        with salt.utils.fopen(template_path, 'r') as fp_:
            template = fp_.read()
        ret = self.run_function(
            'state.template_str', [template], timeout=120
        )
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

        # Now using state.template
        ret = self.run_function(
            'state.template', [template_path], timeout=120
        )
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

    def test_template_invalid_items(self):
        TEMPLATE = textwrap.dedent('''\
            {0}:
              - issue-2068-template-str

            /tmp/test-template-invalid-items:
              file:
                - managed
                - source: salt://testfile
            ''')
        for item in ('include', 'exclude', 'extends'):
            ret = self.run_function(
                'state.template_str', [TEMPLATE.format(item)]
            )
            self.assertTrue(isinstance(ret, list))
            self.assertNotEqual(ret, [])
            self.assertEqual(
                ['The \'{0}\' declaration found on \'<template-str>\' is '
                 'invalid when rendering single templates'.format(item)],
                ret
            )

    def test_pydsl(self):
        '''
        Test the basics of the pydsl
        '''
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='pydsl-1')
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

    def test_issues_7905_and_8174_sls_syntax_error(self):
        '''
        Call sls file with yaml syntax error.

        Ensure theses errors are detected and presented to the user without
        stack traces.
        '''
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='syntax.badlist')
        self.assertEqual(ret, [
            'State \'A\' in SLS \'syntax.badlist\' is not formed as a list'
        ])
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='syntax.badlist2')
        self.assertEqual(ret, [
            'State \'C\' in SLS \'syntax.badlist2\' is not formed as a list'
        ])

    def test_requisites_mixed_require_prereq_use(self):
        '''
        Call sls file containing several requisites.
        '''
        expected_simple_result = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True}
        }
        expected_result = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A fifth_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 4,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A fifth" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B third_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B third" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C second_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C second" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-D_|-echo D first_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo D first" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-E_|-echo E fourth_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 3,
                'comment': 'Command "echo E fourth" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True}
        }
        expected_req_use_result = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 4,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-D_|-echo D_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 5,
                'comment': 'Command "echo D" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-E_|-echo E_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo E" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-F_|-echo F_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 3,
                'comment': 'Command "echo F" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True}
        }
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.mixed_simple')
        result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        self.assertEqual(expected_simple_result, result)

        # test Traceback recursion prereq+require #8785
        # TODO: this is actually failing badly
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_require_recursion_error2')
        #self.assertEqual(
        #    ret,
        #    ['A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.prereq_require_recursion_error2" ID "B" ID "A"']
        #)

        # test Infinite recursion prereq+require #8785 v2
        # TODO: this is actually failing badly
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_require_recursion_error3')
        #self.assertEqual(
        #    ret,
        #    ['A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.prereq_require_recursion_error2" ID "B" ID "A"']
        #)

        # test Infinite recursion prereq+require #8785 v3
        # TODO: this is actually failing badly, and expected result is maybe not a recursion
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_require_recursion_error4')
        #self.assertEqual(
        #    ret,
        #    ['A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.prereq_require_recursion_error2" ID "B" ID "A"']
        #)

        # undetected infinite loopS prevents this test from running...
        # TODO: this is actually failing badly
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.mixed_complex1')
        #result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        #self.assertEqual(expected_result, result)

    def test_watch_in(self):
        '''
        test watch_in requisite when there is a success
        '''
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.watch_in')
        changes = 'test_|-return_changes_|-return_changes_|-succeed_with_changes'
        watch = 'test_|-watch_states_|-watch_states_|-succeed_without_changes'

        self.assertEqual(ret[changes]['__run_num__'], 0)
        self.assertEqual(ret[watch]['__run_num__'], 2)

        self.assertEqual('Watch statement fired.', ret[watch]['comment'])
        self.assertEqual('Something pretended to change',
                         ret[changes]['changes']['testing']['new'])

    def test_watch_in_failure(self):
        '''
        test watch_in requisite when there is a failure
        '''
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.watch_in_failure')
        fail = 'test_|-return_changes_|-return_changes_|-fail_with_changes'
        watch = 'test_|-watch_states_|-watch_states_|-succeed_without_changes'

        self.assertEqual(False, ret[fail]['result'])
        self.assertEqual('One or more requisite failed: requisites.watch_in_failure.return_changes',
                         ret[watch]['comment'])

    def normalize_ret(self, ret):
        '''
        Normalize the return to the format that we'll use for result checking
        '''
        result = {}
        for item, descr in six.iteritems(ret):
            result[item] = {
                '__run_num__': descr['__run_num__'],
                'comment': descr['comment'],
                'result': descr['result'],
                'changes': descr['changes'] != {}  # whether there where any changes
            }
        return result

    def test_requisites_require_ordering_and_errors(self):
        '''
        Call sls file containing several require_in and require.

        Ensure that some of them are failing and that the order is right.
        '''
        expected_result = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A fifth_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 4,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A fifth" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True,
            },
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B second_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B second" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True,
            },
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C third_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C third" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True,
            },
            'cmd_|-D_|-echo D first_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo D first" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True,
            },
            'cmd_|-E_|-echo E fourth_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 3,
                'comment': 'Command "echo E fourth" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True,
            },
            'cmd_|-F_|-echo F_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 5,
                'comment': 'The following requisites were not found:\n'
                           + '                   require:\n'
                           + '                       foobar: A\n',
                'result': False,
                'changes': False,
            },
            'cmd_|-G_|-echo G_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 6,
                'comment': 'The following requisites were not found:\n'
                           + '                   require:\n'
                           + '                       cmd: Z\n',
                'result': False,
                'changes': False,
            },
            'cmd_|-H_|-echo H_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 7,
                'comment': 'The following requisites were not found:\n'
                           + '                   require:\n'
                           + '                       cmd: Z\n',
                'result': False,
                'changes': False,
            }
        }
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.require')
        result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        self.assertEqual(expected_result, result)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.require_error1')
        self.assertEqual(ret, [
            "Cannot extend ID 'W' in 'base:requisites.require_error1'. It is not part of the high state.\nThis is likely due to a missing include statement or an incorrectly typed ID.\nEnsure that a state with an ID of 'W' is available\nin environment 'base' and to SLS 'requisites.require_error1'"
        ])

        # issue #8235
        # FIXME: Why is require enforcing list syntax while require_in does not?
        # And why preventing it?
        # Currently this state fails, should return C/B/A
        result = {}
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.require_simple_nolist')
        self.assertEqual(ret, [
            'The require statement in state \'B\' in SLS '
          + '\'requisites.require_simple_nolist\' needs to be formed as a list'
        ])

        # commented until a fix is made for issue #8772
        # TODO: this test actually fails
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.require_error2')
        #self.assertEqual(ret, [
        #    'Cannot extend state foobar for ID A in "base:requisites.require_error2".'
        #    + ' It is not part of the high state.'
        #])

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.require_recursion_error1')
        self.assertEqual(
            ret,
            ['A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.require_recursion_error1" ID "B" ID "A"']
        )

    def test_requisites_full_sls(self):
        '''
        Teste the sls special command in requisites
        '''
        expected_result = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
        }
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.fullsls_require')
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        self.assertEqual(expected_result, result)

        # issue #8233: traceback on prereq sls
        # TODO: not done
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.fullsls_prereq')
        #self.assertEqual(['sls command can only be used with require requisite'], ret)

    def test_requisites_prereq_simple_ordering_and_errors(self):
        '''
        Call sls file containing several prereq_in and prereq.

        Ensure that some of them are failing and that the order is right.
        '''
        expected_result_simple = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A third_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A third" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B first_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B first" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C second_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C second" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-I_|-echo I_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 3,
                'comment': 'The following requisites were not found:\n'
                           + '                   prereq:\n'
                           + '                       cmd: Z\n',
                'result': False,
                'changes': False},
            'cmd_|-J_|-echo J_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 4,
                'comment': 'The following requisites were not found:\n'
                           + '                   prereq:\n'
                           + '                       foobar: A\n',
                'result': False,
                'changes': False}
        }
        expected_result_simple2 = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-D_|-echo D_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 3,
                'comment': 'Command "echo D" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-E_|-echo E_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 4,
                'comment': 'Command "echo E" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True}
        }
        expected_result_simple3 = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A first_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A first" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True,
            },
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B second_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B second" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True,
            },
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C third_|-wait': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': '',
                'result': True,
                'changes': False,
            }
        }
        expected_result_complex = {
            'cmd_|-A_|-echo A fourth_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 3,
                'comment': 'Command "echo A fourth" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-B_|-echo B first_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 0,
                'comment': 'Command "echo B first" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-C_|-echo C second_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 1,
                'comment': 'Command "echo C second" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
            'cmd_|-D_|-echo D third_|-run': {
                '__run_num__': 2,
                'comment': 'Command "echo D third" run',
                'result': True,
                'changes': True},
        }
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_simple')
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        self.assertEqual(expected_result_simple, result)

        # same test, but not using lists in yaml syntax
        # TODO: issue #8235, prereq ignored when not used in list syntax
        # Currently fails badly with :
        # TypeError encountered executing state.sls: string indices must be integers, not str.
        #expected_result_simple.pop('cmd_|-I_|-echo I_|-run')
        #expected_result_simple.pop('cmd_|-J_|-echo J_|-run')
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_simple_nolist')
        #result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        #self.assertEqual(expected_result_simple, result)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_simple2')
        result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        self.assertEqual(expected_result_simple2, result)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_simple3')
        result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        self.assertEqual(expected_result_simple3, result)

        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_error_nolist')
        #self.assertEqual(
        #    ret,
        #    ['Cannot extend ID Z in "base:requisites.prereq_error_nolist".'
        #    + ' It is not part of the high state.']
        #)

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_compile_error1')
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        self.assertEqual(
            ret['cmd_|-B_|-echo B_|-run']['comment'],
            'The following requisites were not found:\n'
            + '                   prereq:\n'
            + '                       foobar: A\n'
        )

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_compile_error2')
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        self.assertEqual(
            ret['cmd_|-B_|-echo B_|-run']['comment'],
            'The following requisites were not found:\n'
            + '                   prereq:\n'
            + '                       foobar: C\n'
        )

        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_complex')
        result = self.normalize_ret(ret)
        self.assertEqual(expected_result_complex, result)

        # issue #8210 : prereq recursion undetected
        # TODO: this test fails
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_recursion_error')
        #self.assertEqual(
        #    ret,
        #    ['A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.prereq_recursion_error" ID "B" ID "A"']
        #)
    def test_infinite_recursion_sls_prereq(self):
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.prereq_sls_infinite_recursion')
        self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)

    def test_requisites_use(self):
        '''
        Call sls file containing several use_in and use.

        '''
        # TODO issue #8235 & #8774 some examples are still commented in the test file
        ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.use')
        self.assertReturnNonEmptySaltType(ret)
        for item, descr in six.iteritems(ret):
            self.assertEqual(descr['comment'], 'onlyif execution failed')

        # TODO: issue #8802 : use recursions undetected
        # issue is closed as use does not actually inherit requisites
        # if chain-use is added after #8774 resolution theses tests would maybe become useful
        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.use_recursion')
        #self.assertEqual(ret, [
        #    'A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.use_recursion"'
        #    + ' ID "B" ID "A"'
        #])

        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.use_recursion2')
        #self.assertEqual(ret, [
        #    'A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.use_recursion2"'
        #    + ' ID "C" ID "A"'
        #])

        #ret = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.use_auto_recursion')
        #self.assertEqual(ret, [
        #    'A recursive requisite was found, SLS "requisites.use_recursion"'
        #    + ' ID "A" ID "A"'
        #])

    def test_get_file_from_env_in_top_match(self):
        tgt = os.path.join(TMP, 'prod-cheese-file')
        try:
            ret = self.run_function(
                'state.highstate', minion_tgt='sub_minion'
            )
            self.assertSaltTrueReturn(ret)
            self.assertTrue(os.path.isfile(tgt))
            with salt.utils.fopen(tgt, 'r') as cheese:
                data = cheese.read()
                self.assertIn('Gromit', data)
                self.assertIn('Comte', data)
        finally:
            if os.path.islink(tgt):
                os.unlink(tgt)

    # onchanges tests

    def test_onchanges_requisite(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the onchanges requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onchanges_simple')

        # First, test the result of the state run when changes are expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_changing_state_|-echo "Success!"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'Command "echo "Success!"" run'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

        # Then, test the result of the state run when changes are not expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_non_changing_state_|-echo "Should not run"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'State was not run because none of the onchanges reqs changed'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

    def test_onchanges_requisite_multiple(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the onchanges requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls',
                mods='requisites.onchanges_multiple')

        # First, test the result of the state run when two changes are expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_two_changing_states_|-echo "Success!"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'Command "echo "Success!"" run'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

        # Then, test the result of the state run when two changes are not expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_two_non_changing_states_|-echo "Should not run"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'State was not run because none of the onchanges reqs changed'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

        # Finally, test the result of the state run when only one of the onchanges requisites changes.
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_one_changing_state_|-echo "Success!"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'Command "echo "Success!"" run'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

    def test_onchanges_in_requisite(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the onchanges_in requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onchanges_in_simple')

        # First, test the result of the state run of when changes are expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_changes_expected_|-echo "Success!"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'Command "echo "Success!"" run'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

        # Then, test the result of the state run when changes are not expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_changes_not_expected_|-echo "Should not run"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'State was not run because none of the onchanges reqs changed'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

    def test_onchanges_requisite_with_duration(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the onchanges requisite
        the state will not run but results will include duration
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onchanges_simple')

        # Then, test the result of the state run when changes are not expected to happen
        # and ensure duration is included in the results
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_non_changing_state_|-echo "Should not run"_|-run']
        self.assertIn('duration', test_data)

    # onfail tests

    def test_onfail_requisite(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the onfail requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onfail_simple')

        # First, test the result of the state run when a failure is expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_failing_state_|-echo "Success!"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'Command "echo "Success!"" run'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

        # Then, test the result of the state run when a failure is not expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_non_failing_state_|-echo "Should not run"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'State was not run because onfail req did not change'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

    def test_multiple_onfail_requisite(self):
        '''
        test to ensure state is run even if only one
        of the onfails fails. This is a test for the issue:
        https://github.com/saltstack/salt/issues/22370
        '''

        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onfail_multiple')

        retcode = state_run['cmd_|-c_|-echo itworked_|-run']['changes']['retcode']
        self.assertEqual(retcode, 0)

        stdout = state_run['cmd_|-c_|-echo itworked_|-run']['changes']['stdout']
        self.assertEqual(stdout, 'itworked')

    def test_onfail_in_requisite(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the onfail_in requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onfail_in_simple')

        # First, test the result of the state run when a failure is expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_failing_state_|-echo "Success!"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'Command "echo "Success!"" run'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

        # Then, test the result of the state run when a failure is not expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_non_failing_state_|-echo "Should not run"_|-run']['comment']
        expected_result = 'State was not run because onfail req did not change'
        self.assertIn(expected_result, test_data)

    def test_onfail_requisite_with_duration(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the onfail requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onfail_simple')

        # Then, test the result of the state run when a failure is not expected to happen
        test_data = state_run['cmd_|-test_non_failing_state_|-echo "Should not run"_|-run']
        self.assertIn('duration', test_data)

    def test_multiple_onfail_requisite_with_required(self):
        '''
        test to ensure multiple states are run
        when specified as onfails for a single state.
        This is a test for the issue:
        https://github.com/saltstack/salt/issues/46552
        '''

        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onfail_multiple_required')

        retcode = state_run['cmd_|-b_|-echo b_|-run']['changes']['retcode']
        self.assertEqual(retcode, 0)

        retcode = state_run['cmd_|-c_|-echo c_|-run']['changes']['retcode']
        self.assertEqual(retcode, 0)

        retcode = state_run['cmd_|-d_|-echo d_|-run']['changes']['retcode']
        self.assertEqual(retcode, 0)

        stdout = state_run['cmd_|-b_|-echo b_|-run']['changes']['stdout']
        self.assertEqual(stdout, 'b')

        stdout = state_run['cmd_|-c_|-echo c_|-run']['changes']['stdout']
        self.assertEqual(stdout, 'c')

        stdout = state_run['cmd_|-d_|-echo d_|-run']['changes']['stdout']
        self.assertEqual(stdout, 'd')

    def test_multiple_onfail_requisite_with_required_no_run(self):
        '''
        test to ensure multiple states are not run
        when specified as onfails for a single state
        which fails.
        This is a test for the issue:
        https://github.com/saltstack/salt/issues/46552
        '''

        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.onfail_multiple_required_no_run')

        expected = 'State was not run because onfail req did not change'

        stdout = state_run['cmd_|-b_|-echo b_|-run']['comment']
        self.assertEqual(stdout, expected)

        stdout = state_run['cmd_|-c_|-echo c_|-run']['comment']
        self.assertEqual(stdout, expected)

        stdout = state_run['cmd_|-d_|-echo d_|-run']['comment']
        self.assertEqual(stdout, expected)

    # listen tests

    def test_listen_requisite(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the listen requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.listen_simple')

        # First, test the result of the state run when a listener is expected to trigger
        listener_state = 'cmd_|-listener_test_listening_change_state_|-echo "Listening State"_|-mod_watch'
        self.assertIn(listener_state, state_run)

        # Then, test the result of the state run when a listener should not trigger
        absent_state = 'cmd_|-listener_test_listening_non_changing_state_|-echo "Only run once"_|-mod_watch'
        self.assertNotIn(absent_state, state_run)

    def test_listen_in_requisite(self):
        '''
        Tests a simple state using the listen_in requisite
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.listen_in_simple')

        # First, test the result of the state run when a listener is expected to trigger
        listener_state = 'cmd_|-listener_test_listening_change_state_|-echo "Listening State"_|-mod_watch'
        self.assertIn(listener_state, state_run)

        # Then, test the result of the state run when a listener should not trigger
        absent_state = 'cmd_|-listener_test_listening_non_changing_state_|-echo "Only run once"_|-mod_watch'
        self.assertNotIn(absent_state, state_run)

    def test_listen_in_requisite_resolution(self):
        '''
        Verify listen_in requisite lookups use ID declaration to check for changes
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.listen_in_simple')

        # Test the result of the state run when a listener is expected to trigger
        listener_state = 'cmd_|-listener_test_listen_in_resolution_|-echo "Successful listen_in resolution"_|-mod_watch'
        self.assertIn(listener_state, state_run)

    def test_listen_requisite_resolution(self):
        '''
        Verify listen requisite lookups use ID declaration to check for changes
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.listen_simple')

        # Both listeners are expected to trigger
        listener_state = 'cmd_|-listener_test_listening_resolution_one_|-echo "Successful listen resolution"_|-mod_watch'
        self.assertIn(listener_state, state_run)

        listener_state = 'cmd_|-listener_test_listening_resolution_two_|-echo "Successful listen resolution"_|-mod_watch'
        self.assertIn(listener_state, state_run)

    def test_listen_in_requisite_resolution_names(self):
        '''
        Verify listen_in requisite lookups use ID declaration to check for changes
        and resolves magic names state variable
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.listen_in_names')
        self.assertIn('test_|-listener_service_|-nginx_|-mod_watch', state_run)
        self.assertIn('test_|-listener_service_|-crond_|-mod_watch', state_run)

    def test_listen_requisite_resolution_names(self):
        '''
        Verify listen requisite lookups use ID declaration to check for changes
        and resolves magic names state variable
        '''

        # Only run the state once and keep the return data
        state_run = self.run_function('state.sls', mods='requisites.listen_names')
        self.assertIn('test_|-listener_service_|-nginx_|-mod_watch', state_run)
        self.assertIn('test_|-listener_service_|-crond_|-mod_watch', state_run)

    def test_issue_30820_requisite_in_match_by_name(self):
        '''
        This tests the case where a requisite_in matches by name instead of ID

        See https://github.com/saltstack/salt/issues/30820 for more info
        '''
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='requisites.requisite_in_match_by_name'
        )
        bar_state = 'cmd_|-bar state_|-echo bar_|-wait'

        self.assertIn(bar_state, state_run)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[bar_state]['comment'],
                         'Command "echo bar" run')

    def test_retry_option_defaults(self):
        '''
        test the retry option on a simple state with defaults
        ensure comment is as expected
        ensure state duration is greater than default retry_interval (30 seconds)
        '''
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='retry.retry_defaults'
        )
        retry_state = 'file_|-file_test_|-/path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt_|-exists'
        expected_comment = ('Attempt 1: Returned a result of "False", with the following '
                'comment: "Specified path /path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt does not exist"\n'
                'Specified path /path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt does not exist')
        self.assertEqual(state_run[retry_state]['comment'], expected_comment)
        self.assertTrue(state_run[retry_state]['duration'] > 30)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[retry_state]['result'], False)

    def test_retry_option_custom(self):
        '''
        test the retry option on a simple state with custom retry values
        ensure comment is as expected
        ensure state duration is greater than custom defined interval * (retries - 1)
        '''
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='retry.retry_custom'
        )
        retry_state = 'file_|-file_test_|-/path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt_|-exists'
        expected_comment = ('Attempt 1: Returned a result of "False", with the following '
                'comment: "Specified path /path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt does not exist"\n'
                'Attempt 2: Returned a result of "False", with the following comment: "Specified'
                ' path /path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt does not exist"\nAttempt 3: Returned'
                ' a result of "False", with the following comment: "Specified path'
                ' /path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt does not exist"\nAttempt 4: Returned a'
                ' result of "False", with the following comment: "Specified path'
                ' /path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt does not exist"\nSpecified path'
                ' /path/to/a/non-existent/file.txt does not exist')
        self.assertEqual(state_run[retry_state]['comment'], expected_comment)
        self.assertTrue(state_run[retry_state]['duration'] > 40)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[retry_state]['result'], False)

    def test_retry_option_success(self):
        '''
        test a state with the retry option that should return True immedietly (i.e. no retries)
        '''
        testfile = os.path.join(TMP, 'retry_file')
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='retry.retry_success'
        )
        os.unlink(testfile)
        retry_state = 'file_|-file_test_|-{0}_|-exists'.format(testfile)
        self.assertNotIn('Attempt', state_run[retry_state]['comment'])

    def run_create(self):
        '''
        helper function to wait 30 seconds and then create the temp retry file
        '''
        testfile = os.path.join(TMP, 'retry_file')
        time.sleep(30)
        open(testfile, 'a').close()  # pylint: disable=resource-leakage

    def test_retry_option_eventual_success(self):
        '''
        test a state with the retry option that should return True after at least 4 retry attmempt
        but never run 15 attempts
        '''
        testfile = os.path.join(TMP, 'retry_file')
        create_thread = threading.Thread(target=self.run_create)
        create_thread.start()
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='retry.retry_success2'
        )
        retry_state = 'file_|-file_test_|-{0}_|-exists'.format(testfile)
        self.assertIn('Attempt 1:', state_run[retry_state]['comment'])
        self.assertIn('Attempt 2:', state_run[retry_state]['comment'])
        self.assertIn('Attempt 3:', state_run[retry_state]['comment'])
        self.assertIn('Attempt 4:', state_run[retry_state]['comment'])
        self.assertNotIn('Attempt 15:', state_run[retry_state]['comment'])
        self.assertEqual(state_run[retry_state]['result'], True)

    def test_issue_38683_require_order_failhard_combination(self):
        '''
        This tests the case where require, order, and failhard are all used together in a state definition.

        Previously, the order option, which used in tandem with require and failhard, would cause the state
        compiler to stacktrace. This exposed a logic error in the ``check_failhard`` function of the state
        compiler. With the logic error resolved, this test should now pass.

        See https://github.com/saltstack/salt/issues/38683 for more information.
        '''
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='requisites.require_order_failhard_combo'
        )
        state_id = 'test_|-b_|-b_|-fail_with_changes'

        self.assertIn(state_id, state_run)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[state_id]['comment'], 'Failure!')
        self.assertFalse(state_run[state_id]['result'])

    def test_issue_46762_prereqs_on_a_state_with_unfulfilled_requirements(self):
        '''
        This tests the case where state C requires state A which fails.
        State C is a prereq for State B.

        See https://github.com/saltstack/salt/issues/46762 for
        more information.
        '''
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='issue-46762'
        )

        state_id = 'test_|-a_|-a_|-fail_without_changes'
        self.assertIn(state_id, state_run)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[state_id]['comment'],
                         'Failure!')
        self.assertFalse(state_run[state_id]['result'])

        state_id = 'test_|-b_|-b_|-nop'
        self.assertIn(state_id, state_run)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[state_id]['comment'],
                         'One or more requisite failed: issue-46762.c')
        self.assertFalse(state_run[state_id]['result'])

        state_id = 'test_|-c_|-c_|-nop'
        self.assertIn(state_id, state_run)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[state_id]['comment'],
                         'One or more requisite failed: issue-46762.a')
        self.assertFalse(state_run[state_id]['result'])

    def test_state_nonbase_environment(self):
        '''
        test state.sls with saltenv using a nonbase environment
        with a salt source
        '''
        file_name = os.path.join(TMP, 'nonbase_env')
        state_run = self.run_function(
            'state.sls',
            mods='non-base-env',
            saltenv='prod'
        )
        state_id = 'file_|-test_file_|-{0}_|-managed'.format(file_name)
        self.assertEqual(state_run[state_id]['comment'],
                         'File {0} updated'.format(file_name))
        self.assertTrue(
            state_run['file_|-test_file_|-{0}_|-managed'.format(file_name)]['result'])
        self.assertTrue(os.path.isfile(file_name))

    def tearDown(self):
        nonbase_file = os.path.join(TMP, 'nonbase_env')
        if os.path.isfile(nonbase_file):
            os.remove(nonbase_file)